Law Office of
Ravi Patel
Book a Free Consultation

When a Creditor Comes After an Heir Who Took a House by Primary Residence Petition

A primary residence petition lets heirs take a California house worth up to $750,000 without a full probate (Prob. Code, § 13151; § 13152, subd. (f)(3)). The speed comes with a catch many families miss: the heirs who take the house can become personally responsible for the decedent’s unpaid bills. This post explains how far that liability reaches and how to respond when a collector calls.

Each heir who receives the house becomes personally liable for the decedent’s unsecured debts.

The law makes each petitioner who receives property under the court’s order personally liable for the decedent’s unsecured debts (Prob. Code, § 13156, subd. (a)). Unsecured debts have no collateral behind them; credit card balances and medical bills are the common examples. A creditor can pursue any petitioner who took property under the order.

The liability stops at the net value of what that heir received.

The statute caps each petitioner’s liability at the fair market value, at the date of death, of the property that petitioner received, less liens and encumbrances (Prob. Code, § 13156, subd. (b)). Suppose Ana takes her mother’s house by petition. At her mother’s death, the house was worth $600,000 and carried a $250,000 mortgage, so Ana’s cap is $350,000. If her mother left $40,000 in credit card debt, Ana can owe the full $40,000. If her mother owed $500,000, Ana can owe no more than $350,000.

When two or more heirs take the house, the statute caps each one at the value of what that heir received. It does not say how to divide a single mortgage among them. If the numbers are close, get advice.

The heir keeps every defense the decedent had.

In a suit on the debt, the petitioner “may assert any defense, cross-complaint, or setoff which would have been available to the decedent” (Prob. Code, § 13156, subd. (c)). A debt the decedent paid or disputed stays paid or disputed. And a creditor cannot enforce a claim already barred in a probate (id., subd. (d)).

A creditor must sue within one year after the death.

Section 13156 applies Code of Civil Procedure section 366.2 to these claims (Prob. Code, § 13156, subd. (e)). Under section 366.2, a creditor must file suit on the decedent’s liability within one year after the date of death. Nothing tolls or extends that year except the cases the statute lists (Code Civ. Proc., § 366.2, subd. (b)). A creditor who waits longer generally loses the claim against the heir.

Collection usually starts with a letter, and the heir should answer it carefully.

Most collectors start with a letter to the estate or to a family member. Don’t pay from personal funds, or promise to pay, until you know the debt is valid and what your cap allows. Ask the collector for an itemized statement and proof that the decedent owed the debt. Write down the date of death and the date one year later. If the creditor sues, the suit names the heir personally, because section 13156 makes the liability personal. File a response by the deadline on the summons, and raise the cap and the decedent’s defenses in it.

Probate cuts off late claims, and the petition does not.

In a probate, a creditor must file a claim within four months after letters first issue, or within 60 days after the personal representative mails or delivers notice to the creditor, whichever is later (Prob. Code, § 9100, subd. (a)). The law bars a claim not filed on time (Prob. Code, § 9002, subd. (b)). The petition has no claim period, so the one-year statute is the only cutoff.

Someone may open a probate later, for example to collect other assets. Creditors then file claims there, and the petitioner can raise that probate’s bar against any claim the creditor failed to file on time (Prob. Code, § 13156, subd. (d)). Once final, the petition order itself stays “conclusive on all persons” (Prob. Code, § 13155).

The mortgage stays with the house and lowers the cap.

Section 13156 reaches only unsecured debts. The house secures the mortgage, so the lender looks to the house, and an heir who keeps the house keeps paying. The mortgage, as an encumbrance, also reduces the heir’s cap. Federal law bars a lender from calling a home loan due because the house passed to a relative at the borrower’s death (12 U.S.C. § 1701j-3(d)(5)).

Medi-Cal must receive notice of the death.

If the decedent received or may have received Medi-Cal, the beneficiary or the person holding the decedent’s property must notify the Department of Health Care Services within 90 days after the death and include a death certificate (Prob. Code, § 215). The department accepts the notice online. For deaths on or after January 1, 2017, the statute limits recovery to the probate estate and requires the department to waive its claim against a homestead of modest value (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 14009.5, subds. (c)(2), (f)(3), (g)). Whether a Medi-Cal claim reaches a house that passed by petition is an area where the particular facts can determine the outcome. If you have concerns, consult an attorney.

Ask about debts before choosing the petition, and hold sale proceeds until a year after the death.

At intake, ask about every debt: credit cards, medical bills, loans, Medi-Cal and unpaid taxes. When the debts run large compared to the equity, a probate and its claim cutoff may protect the heirs better than the petition. If the heirs sell, consider holding enough of the proceeds in a blocked account until a year after the death.

For how to prove the residence in the first place, see our guide to finding out whether a house has a homeowners’ exemption.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.